The trillion-dollar question: Can Facebook's virtual assistant succeed where others have failed?

Apple's Siri: one of the first virtual assistants on smartphone.
Apple's Siri: one of the first virtual assistants on smartphone.

A vision of the future from Mindshare's head of mobile: Think of a world where Facebook knows where you are, where your next meeting is, and how long it'll take you to get there,

As artificial intelligence and machine learning progress apace, virtual assistants (digital services looking after a range of our needs) are set to become our gateway to the Internet and know more about us than we do ourselves.

As a result, the evolution of the virtual assistant is something that we have been keeping a close eye on here at Mindshare over the past couple of years.

Apple and Google’s iterations of the virtual assistant are already well documented, and with Microsoft’s Cortana leading the way in the field, it was only a matter of time before Facebook also entered the fray.

Adoption of these services has been slow so far, but a research study into Virtual Assistants undertaken last year by Mindshare’s Future_Medialab and London Goldsmith’s University showed that there is a strong latent interest in the concept. Sixty-two percent of smartphone users are interested in using a virtual assistant.

The same study also showed that while there was some enthusiasm for a paid-for, ad-free model (18 %), The setudy asll  was an expectation that as the virtual assistant gained more knowledge about the user, ad funded recommendations could be introduced that were genuinely useful to the user. Forth-six percent of those surveyed felt that a tradeoff with a free Virtual Assistant with relevant advertising would be their preferred option.

Facebook definitely have one eye on the advertising pie with the introduction of M. Think of a world where Facebook knows where you are, where your next meeting is, and how long it’ll take you to get there (as Cortana already does). Cue paid advertising from Uber encouraging you to book one of their cars, rather than taking the bus.

Advertising opportunities exist for every advertiser — large or small. BP could remind you to stop and fill up your car at one of their gas stations before you go on your road trip, while a local restaurant could pitch to host you for dinner.

And the potential ad revenues don’t stop at reservations. Don’t forget, all this data can be used better to target Facebook’s in-feed advertising.

Facebook’s paid advertising proposition has always been about advertising to people rather than to audience segments, and the knowledge of your habits will take this concept to another next level.

This, added to the rumors of Facebook using keywords in WhatsApp conversations to better target their in-feed advertising, and using Facebook login data to target people across device, outside of Facebook, via Atlas, is likely to make them the most compelling media property on the planet.

So, the trillion-dollar question is this: Can Facebook make the virtual assistant work where Apple, Google and Microsoft have struggled?

David Marcus (the vice president of messaging products at Facebook) has an impressive track record. In one year at Facebook, he’s doubled the user base of the Messenger app to 700 million, and Facebook’s approach to how M works is also interesting – asking followup questions as a message thread

It’s impossible to tell whether M will be a success. What I can say is that when the initiative rolls out in the UK, It will prompt me to install Messenger on my phone. Something I have to date refused to do.

Neil Bruce is the head of mobile at Mindshare.

This article first appeared on

Subscribe today for just $116 a year

Get the very latest news and insight from Campaign with unrestricted access to , plus get exclusive discounts to Campaign events

Become a subscriber


The latest work, news, advice, comment and analysis, sent to you every day

register free